Showing posts with label coca-cola. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coca-cola. Show all posts

Monday, November 14, 2011

Captain Charles Moore's New Book, "Plastic Ocean"

I first learned of Captain Charles Moore in a Discovery Channel documentary in 2009. He was strolling the plastic sand at Hawaii's infamous Kamilo Beach, exposing the realities of a plastic society. Since then, he and the pioneering work of his non-profit, Algalita Marine Research Foundation, have loomed large in the back of my mind & in my efforts. It looms still larger, now that I've just finished his brand-new "Plastic Ocean" (with collaborator Cassandra Phillips).



"Plastic Ocean" is something of an enigma -- as I imagine Capt. Moore to be. It's part personal narrative, part adventure tale, part history/science lecture, part manifesto. It follows no real chronology. But it thinks big. In it, Moore cuts a broad (and occasionally deep) swath through the invention of plastics, methods of plastic production, international treaties on plastic dumping, scientific literature listing the ills of plastic, collaborations with scientists & artists, joint ventures, a walk-through of how a scientific paper gets into peer-reviewed journals. And he sums it up with a clarion call for a complete rethinking of what it means for a society to be prosperous and successful.

No small work, this.

Its 337 pages take the reader through turbulent swells, doldrums blazing with hot sun and heavy air, refreshing dips in clear lagoons. An occasional statement threatens to capsize the whole thing. (He cites the "100,000 animals killed each year" figure, which has been floating around as an untested number since 1984. He also raises the spectre of plastic pellets being used to fatten cattle, although various searches reveal only a grainy newspaper article from 1971 about this being tried.) Yet somehow it all works, and the pages keep turning.

In the end, this is a love story. A vision & memory of wide seas, roaring surf, sparkling beaches. Simpler times and tastes, before the throwaway world, when people made crafts -- and crafted things were built to last. Every good love story has its crisis. And of course the crisis here is plastic waste, and its attendant soup of toxic chemicals that foul seas, beaches, & marine life. But plastic itself is not the villain. Cheap, disposable plastics and the companies who shamelessly make, promote, and defend them in spite of mounting evidence of their harm -- these cast the shadow across this text. Moore has no love for the American Chemistry Council or bottling giant Coca-Cola. He has little patience for organizations who receive large checks from them and still profess to be seriously working on the problem of plastic pollution.

Moore also devotes many pages to exposing the still-growing destruction caused by fishing debris -- decimated coral reefs, dead & injured sea creatures, hazards to shipping & sailing. (The latter of which he experienced first-hand and recounts vividly.) He shows convincingly that international treaties such as MARPOL Annex V (1988) are toothless tigers, flouted by many rogue fishing fleets still today.

"Plastic Ocean" is literally chock-a-bloc with facts and figures. Sadly, with no footnotes it's hard for a reader to take further steps to delve into these figures themselves. (It does contain a well-stocked general bibliography at the back.) Moore notes this as a conscious choice, but his logic isn't exactly satisfying. Still, this book is a powerful wake-up call to a modern dystopia of our own making. It's a great introduction for people who are just learning of the problem. And even seasoned plastic-pollution fighters will find details & angles that they hadn't considered before.

As the pages turn, and solution after solution is vetted -- and shot down -- the scale of the problem and the need to change the game at the source becomes ever more clear. We cannot quickly clean up the mess we've made. There's no way to do it. We just have to stop adding to it.

Capt. Moore writes, "The seductive idea that the more we consume, the better off we'll be has timed out, and the Plastic Ocean is one of many witnesses to this fact... The ocean planet will thank you if you help end its plastic plague." I can't tell whether he looks to the future with optimism or pessimism. Either way, his words ring true.

Monday, May 30, 2011

Plastic Is a Gas

The latest buzz from the big multinational bottlers is plant plastics. Giants like Coke and Pepsi have unleashed a flurry of press releases touting this "green" invention. And self-professed green blogs eat up the writings of PR/marketing departments as fact. Or worse, misunderstand the facts, spreading misinformation.
From www.acleanpeace.com -- in an article that gets
its facts badly wrong about Pepsi's new product
So is this invention actually green? Set aside the logic of locking nature's nutrients and compost into polymers that nothing in nature will break back down. Just look at the argument that plastic from plants reduces our use of fossil fuels.

Since plastic is petroleum-based, switching to plants will free us of a major source of petroleum dependency, right?

Wrong.

There's a lot of confusion & spin about this, and it's time to clear that up. #1, #2, #4, and #5 plastic comes from ethane. Ethane is a waste by-product found in natural gas fields and oil wells. It is a volatile, hot-burning natural gas. It is so unstable burns so hot that, by U.S. & UK law, it must be separated and removed from the methane that constitutes "normal" natural gas before that methane is piped around the land. And we've all seen images of oil refineries flaring off gas:
Gas flare in Thailand
(picture from Wikimedia Commons)
That's ethane (p. 6 in the PDF file). It's so useless to this refiner that it's just burned right into the air. Junk.

As the plastics industry was being born in the years leading to World War II, someone learned that ethane can be converted to ethylene (and propylene) by steam-cracking. Basically, a hydrocarbon like ethane is mixed with steam, then flash-heated in an oxygen-free furnace to a very high temperature. By tweaking the temperature & hydrocarbons, you can come out with a whole laundry list of petrochemicals. But most of what you get is ethylene & propylene. These can then be polymerized into the polyethylene that makes up #1, #2, and #4 plastics, or the polypropylene that makes up #5. **

At last, some refiners finally had an outlet for all that ethane. (Though as the picture above makes clear, the world still produces far more of it than can be used.)

In short: Nobody drills an oil well to make plastic. Nobody fracks a gas field to make plastic. Plastic comes from the unavoidable, and otherwise mostly unusable, waste by-product of fossil fuel refining. If plastic were suddenly, miraculously removed from the world tomorrow, not one well or field would close shop.

Steam-cracking is energy intensive. There's an agument that getting plastic from plants is less so. That somehow this reduces fossil fuel use. There's two problems with this line of reasoning:
  1. The science is secret; there's no way to know how much energy it really takes to convert plant matter all the way into polymers.
  2. There's also no breakdown of how much energy it takes to grow the plant material. Agriculture is extremely energy intensive. Stocks must be planted, fertilized, weeded, watered, harvested, dried, processed, transported -- all of which is only to make yet another plastic bottle.
Creating plastic from plants is not about being green, being responsible. It's about being seen as green & responsible. So far, traditional journalism has been far too complacent in helping the process. Don't get fooled.

** Ethylene is also a precursor to creating PVC (#3 plastic), and ethane is now even being used to create styrene, from which #6 plastic, polystyrene, can be produced.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Swimming Upstream

I hear talk that the tide is turning in the fight against plastic pollution. That laws are being passed, people are waking up, corporations are coming up with solutions. A sense of hope that scenes like this:
Ocean Park, Maine
or this:
Albatross belly, Midway Atoll, North Pacific
(site: soaronhirschi.blogspot.com/2010/11/
question-for-noaa-and-alldid-these-flip.html)
will soon be a thing of the past.

Reality check. Corporations are not poised to shun plastic. Quite the opposite. In our household, no product we've been using has turned away from plastic. In fact, we've noticed:

* Snapple, formerly bottled in glass, is now bottled in #1 PET.
* Honest Tea, formerly bottled in glass, is now bottled in #1 PET.
* Noxzema, formerly bottled in glass, is now bottled in #5 PP.
* Nivea aftershave, formerly glass, now unidentified plastic.
* Tom's of Maine toothpaste, once aluminum, now unid'ed plastic.

Among others.

The trend is global. In Europe, the plastic industry is nearing a tipping point: public acceptance of #1 plastic for beer/wine. Long a stronghold of glass, beer has begun to come in plastic in Eastern Europe. It's poised to enter the massive Western market. Elsewhere, Coke in Indonesia is ramping up its single-use #1 PET bottles in a nation that already can't handle the waste produced today.

More insidious is the trend to bioplastics. Turning food or compost into persistent, undecomposable polymers is folly. Yet self-described "green" blogs have fawned over the announcements, with only a few voices doing honest journalism and asking questions.

Couple this with high-profile failures in the Bottle-2-Bottle recycling world. In March, Coke quietly pulled the plug on its vaunted plant in Spartanburg, SC. This happened at precisely the same time that a rep from Coke was addressing the Marine Debris Conference, touting its commitment to recycling. Turns out that, surprising nobody, turning old plastic into new, food-quality plastic is extremely hard. Even "easy to recycle" #1 PET.

More and more of what we use is made of plastic. Whether that plastic is from oil, gas, compost, or sugarcane, it's still persistent, hard to refashion cleanly & cheaply, and deadly once in the environment. Millions of tons of new, virgin plastic are created each year. The old "recycled" stuff mostly becomes cheap feedstock for the stuff you see & buy at big box retailers.

Look at everything in your house that isn't yet made of plastic. Somewhere, there's an engineer in a company trying to change that. And some of every new thing made from plastic that was formerly made from paper, glass, wood, aluminum, steel, or anything else will end up in our persistently polluted oceans.

There are real successes in curbing the spread of this waste. Plastic bag bans and taxes are slowly making headway, despite the efforts of the American Chemistry Council with its dishonest "Bag the Ban" Web site and the equally misleading "Save the Plastic Bag" operation. A 9-year-old boy in Vermont is opening many eyes to the silliness of throwing away 500 million plastic straws a day. And speaking of tipping points, I'm an optimist that there will be a global tipping point against this rampant, unchecked pollution.

But for now, those of us who see the damage that our plastic world is causing have to be honest: The reach of plastics is growing, not shrinking. If we recognize and admit that, there's a better chance we can do something about it.